Welcome to Mud Puddle Toys, an old fashioned neighborhood toy store located in seaside Marblehead, Massachusetts. Mud Puddle has been a staple of downtown Marblehead since 2003.

First, we have a few items we'd like to boast about, including:

• BONS Editors and/or Readers Choice award 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, and 2025.
• Marblehead Chamber of Commerce Business of the Year 2022.
• Women-owned since 2003!
• We donate more than $5,000 worth of toys a year to local charities and school. Marblehead Current Toy store supports teachers with $5K in toys, supplies

Our Team

At Mud Puddle you will find our small but mighty team -- Naeemah Adams, Sarah Shairs, and owner Cassie Sturdivant. Read more about our amazing team here:

Marblehead Current: Business Spotlight Mud Puddle Toys
Marblehead Current: Chamber of Commerce Celebrates Great Leadership and Service

Cassie and Naeemah--who met when their boys were in preschool together-- joined together in 2021 when Cassie, a local mom of three, took over ownership. Sarah joined the team part-time in 2024 to help us millennials with our marketing and instagram.

Read more about us below!